” and then he asked if I could also just, generally, fix his marriage, while I had his shoulder,” Phoebe said, “which I told him, that’s not really the service, but I did give him a pretty aggressive opinion about it for free.”
The candle on the table between them had burned down to something shapeless, and the tea in both their mugs had gone from hot to warm to a temperature neither of them was going to mention out loud, because mentioning it would mean noticing how long they’d been sitting here, and neither of them wanted to be the one who noticed first.
Mike laughed the kind that came up from somewhere real, not performed for the room, because there wasn’t a room, there was just the two of them and a couch that had opinions about how a person sat on it.
“Did the marriage get fixed?”
“No, but he tipped great, so, everybody wins something.”
Somewhere in the last several hours the conversation had stopped being two people finding out what the other one did for a living and started being something with no clear shape, no clear direction, a thing that went wherever the next sentence wanted to go.
They’d covered her clients and his rehearsal dinners.
They’d covered the neighbor and the noise complaints in more detail than either topic strictly deserved.
At some point Mike genuinely couldn’t have said when it had turned toward families, the way conversations that run long enough always eventually do, like water finding the low point in a floor.
“So your parents,” Phoebe said, legs tucked under her, chin on her knee, watching him, patient, long since taught to let silences do the work.
“What’s the deal.”
“Old money.
Disapprove of the piano.
Would prefer I’d stayed a lawyer and married someone with a family crest.”
“That’s very economical of you.
Most people take longer to say that.”
“I’ve had practice saying it.”
She kept watching him not suspiciously, not yet, just closely, the way she’d watch a magic trick she couldn’t find the seam in.
He didn’t fidget.
He didn’t reach for a joke to blunt it.
He just said the true thing in the fewest words it needed and let it sit there, and something about that the ease of it, the lack of flinch made her go quiet in a way that was different from her other quiets, more watchful, filing something for later that he couldn’t see and didn’t try to.
“Huh,” she said again, the same sound from the coffee shop, the sound she made when a sum came out different than expected.
“What.”
“Nothing.
You’re just ” She stopped, reconsidered, picked a different word.
“Most people, when I ask about the bad parent stuff, either perform it or dodge it.
You did neither.
It’s interesting.”
“Is interesting good?”
“Interesting is interesting.
I’m still collecting data.” She said it lightly, but there was a real thread under the lightness, and Mike heard it the way he heard a room’s key not because he was trying to, but because he couldn’t not.
His legs had gone numb somewhere around the mother anecdote and he only noticed now, shifting them, feeling the pins-and-needles flood back in with the plain indignity of a body reminding you it existed.
Phoebe watched him wince through it with open delight.
“That’s very undignified,” she said.
“I’m aware.”
“Keep going.
I want the whole recovery.”
He gave her the whole recovery an ungainly few seconds of stamping one foot against the floor like a man putting out a small, personal fire and she laughed at him properly this time, unguarded, and something in the room settled a half-step, like a held note finally landing on the note it had been reaching for all along.
The quiet that came after wasn’t awkward.
That was the part that surprised him the ease of a silence that didn’t need filling.
They’d drifted, sometime in the last hour, from sitting across the low table to sitting on the same side of it, not touching, exactly, but close enough that the not-touching had started to feel like its own kind of statement, a sentence with all the words left out on purpose.
Phoebe broke it first, quiet, flat, no song in it at all.
“I’m not going to sleep with you tonight.”
It wasn’t a question, and it wasn’t fishing for a reaction, either she said it the way she’d said the thing about Hank, like a fact that had already been decided somewhere else and she was just the one reporting it back to the room.
“Okay,” Mike said.
“That’s it?
Just okay?”
“I wasn’t going to ask.
So it’s an easy yes to a question nobody asked.” He thought about that a second.
“That came out weirder than I meant it to.”
“No, I liked it.
It was very ” she searched for the word, didn’t quite find it, which for her was rare enough to be worth noticing, ” unbothered.
I don’t trust unbothered, either, for the record.
It’s going on the list, with smooth.”
“How long’s the list.”
“Getting longer by the hour.
You’re a very suspicious person to talk to.”
He caught himself starting to build the response to that something clever about categories, about how being easy to talk to and being suspicious weren’t actually opposites, a whole small architecture of a point he could make if he wanted to and felt it stack up behind his teeth before he’d said a word of it.
He let it go unbuilt.
“I should probably let you sleep,” he said instead.
“You’ve got the four o’clock.
Feet, not backs.”
“I do have the four o’clock.” She didn’t move to get up.
Neither did he, for a second, and the second stretched into something that wasn’t quite awkward but wasn’t quite nothing, either the low, held tension of two people both waiting to see who’d be the one to end a good thing on purpose.
He stood first.
It felt, in the moment, like the harder of the two options, and also like the right one.
At the door, guitar case forgotten somewhere behind her on the floor, Phoebe leaned against the frame with her arms loose at her sides, watching him get his coat the way she’d watched him recover his legs like she didn’t want to miss any of it.
“So,” she said.
“This was a whole thing.”
“It was a whole thing.”
He had, somewhere in the last thirty seconds of small talk, half-built a good line to leave on something warm and a little clever, the kind of exit a person could be proud of on the walk home, the kind that would sound, replayed later, exactly as considered as it actually was.
He heard himself starting to reach for it.
He heard, underneath that, the shape of every conversation tonight where the considered version had been worse than the true one.
“I had a good line for this,” he said.
“For leaving.
I built it a minute ago, it was pretty solid, actually and I’m not going to use it.”
Phoebe blinked, caught off guard in a way that seemed to genuinely surprise her.
“Why not?”
“Because it was good.
And I don’t think good’s the thing I actually want to leave you with.”
For a second she didn’t say anything at all just looked at him with an expression that hadn’t fully decided what it was yet, somewhere between amused and unsettled and something else underneath both.
Then she smiled, small and real, the kind that didn’t perform for anybody.
“That’s a pretty good line for a guy who’s not using a line,” she said.
“Yeah,” Mike said.
“I noticed that too, about a second too late.”
She laughed short, surprised out of her and he was still hearing it on the stairs going down, three flights, into a night that had gone, without either of them agreeing to it out loud, from a botched blind date into something with its own weather.
hey quick one before you close the tab.
if the cliffhanger is killing you, the future already exists.
you just need a ticket through.
every chapter the second i finish writing it.
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
P.S.
in a parallel timeline, the rest of this story runs completely free on unwrittenrealm.com.
just saying.
that timeline also has more chapters.