“What happens to us if you lose?”
Orlen the wheelwright asked the question on a grey afternoon with the snow falling soft and steady outside the hall and the great-hearth burning warm behind them.
He had come to Aldric alone, without his daughter or his grandchildren, and his face was the face of a man who had been turning a question over in his mind for a long time and had finally decided it couldn’t wait any longer.
Aldric set down the tally-stick he had been notching.
“If I lose what?”
“The review.
The court.
If Riverrun decides the hall belongs to Rushford, or to the Tullys, or to anyone except you.
What happens to the folk who swore?
The oaths, the Hearth Oath, what becomes of them if there is no hall to be sworn to?”
The question was the hard one.
The question Aldric had been dreading since the night Wat knelt at the hearth.
The question that had no good answer.
“Honestly?” he said.
“Honestly.”
“I don’t know.” Aldric stood and walked to the hearth.
The fire was high.
Nella had been feeding it, her penance for the seed-barley, and the warmth of it was a comfort he didn’t deserve.
“The Hearth Oath is older than the Iron Throne, but it has not been tested in a court in living memory.
If Riverrun rules against us, if the escheat is entered and the hall reverts to Tully, the oaths may mean nothing.
They may bind you to a hall that no longer exists.
They may bind you to me, and I will be a landless bastard with nothing to offer but my word.”
“That is not a reassuring answer.”
“It is the only answer I have.
I will not lie to you.
I will not tell you the oaths are safe when I don’t know if they are.
I will not promise you a future I cannot guarantee.” Aldric turned from the fire and met the old man’s eyes.
“If you swear, you are swearing to a hall that may not survive the spring.
You are binding your grandchildren to a keeper who may have nothing to keep.
If that risk is too great, if you would rather wait, and see, and decide after the review, I will not blame you.
I will not think less of you.
The oath was always meant to be freely given, and a free choice made with open eyes is worth more than a hundred oaths made in ignorance.”
Orlen said nothing for a while.
The fire crackled.
Outside the snow fell.
Somewhere in the hall a child laughed: one of Della’s youngest, the girl with the bare feet who had been so frightened at the ford crossing and was now chasing Corm around the long table.
“You could have lied,” Orlen said.
“You could have told me the oaths were unbreakable.
That the hall was certain.
That Riverrun would rule in your favour.
Most lords would have.”
“I am not a lord.”
“No.
You are something else.” Orlen took a step closer to the hearth.
The old wheelwright’s hands were rough and scarred from a lifetime of working wood, and his eyes carried the wariness of someone promised things before by men who meant none of them.
The ford crossing, when I saw your men with their billhooks, I thought my grandchildren were going to die before I could even tell them I was sorry for bringing them here.
And then you lowered the weapons.
You fed us.
You gave us a fire and a roof and a place at the table, and you never once asked for anything in return.”
“I couldn’t.”
“I know.
That’s what I’m saying.” Orlen knelt, not with Wat’s haste, but slowly, his old knees cracking on the cold stone, the deliberate kneel of someone who has made a decision that will outlast him.
“I will swear.
Not because I believe the court will rule for you.
Not because I think the oath will protect my grandchildren if everything goes wrong.
But because you told me the truth.
Because you are the first man with power over me who ever told me the truth, and that is worth binding to.”
Aldric felt his throat tighten.
The fire in his chest was pulsing, not with warning, not with approval, but with the quiet, steady recognition of a thing correctly done.
He offered Orlen the bread and the salt, and Orlen took them, and when he spoke the old words of the Hearth Oath, the same rolling, archaic riverlands dialect that Wat and Hollis and the others had spoken, he meant every syllable of it.
When he pressed his hand to the warm stone, his light kindled.
It was different from the others.
Not stronger or weaker: the fire didn’t grade lights by strength, but clearer, somehow, as if the honesty of the oath had made the thread more visible.
Aldric felt the old man’s light settle into the constellation of the Kin with a particular, stubborn brightness, and he understood, without words, that a light won by truth was a light that wouldn’t go out easily.
From the doorway, he heard a small sound.
Nella.
She had been listening, had come to find him, probably, with some question about the feast or the stores or her father’s mill, and she had heard the whole thing.
Her face was pale, her eyes wide.
“The hall might be taken,” she said.
It was not a question.
“It might.”
“Even with the oaths.
Even with the fire.
Even with everything.”
“Even then.”
Nella stared at him.
Her hands, the same hands that had hauled water and swept the hearth and baked the bread and nearly ruined the seed-barley, were clenched at her sides, and her face was the face of a child who had just understood something terrible.
“You told him the truth,” she said.
“You told him the oath might be worth nothing.
And he swore anyway.”
“Yes.”
“Because you told him the truth.”
“Yes.”
She was quiet a moment, her jaw working.
“My father swore because the rite was honest.
Hollis swore because the law was old.
Brynna swore because she had nowhere else to go.
Orlen swore because you told him the truth.” She looked up at him, her watchful, careful, twelve-year-old eyes older than they had been at the start of the winter.
“Which one of them is bound the hardest?” Read this novel at g.com for the best experience.
“I don’t know if the fire grades them that way.
I think —” Aldric stopped.
The fire was pulsing in his chest, not with words but with a plain, unshaken certainty that was almost a Hearth-Truth.
“I think the fire cares more about how they swore than why.
An oath sworn from love is not worth more than an oath sworn from desperation.
An oath sworn from hope is not worth more than an oath sworn from fear.
What matters is that they meant it.
That they chose it.
That no one made them.”
“And if the court takes the hall, if the escheat is entered and Riverrun says you’re not a lord and never were, what happens to their oaths then?”
Aldric looked at the fire.
The flames were low now, the embers pulsing orange under a blanket of grey ash.
The same ash he had pushed his bare hand into on the first morning.
The same fire he had coaxed to life with his breath and his hope and the strange, wordless warmth in his chest.
“I don’t know,” he said.
“I honestly don’t know.
And that is the truth, Nella, and the truth is the only thing I can offer anyone.” He turned back to her.
“But I know this: whatever the court decides, I will keep my promise to you.
When you are grown, when you have seen something of the world, the hearth will still be here.
The bread will still be here.
The oath will still mean something.
Even if I am not.”
“You said you would be here.”
“I said I meant to be.
There is a difference.” He put a hand on her shoulder, the same hand that had refused Wat’s easy scapegoat and Hollis’s horse and the temptation to press the hamlet into the oath.
“I mean to be here, Nella.
I mean to win the review and hold the hall and keep the fire lit until I am old enough to be the one offering horses and roads.
But if I am not, if the court rules against us and the hall is lost, your promise is not contingent on my presence.
When you are grown, you will find me, and you will swear if you still want to swear, and I will take your oath wherever I am standing.
That is a bastard’s promise, and it is the only one I have, and it will be kept.”
Nella stared at him a while longer.
Then, without another word, she turned and walked back into the hall, and Aldric didn’t follow her.
But as she went, her hands unclenched at her sides.
Just a little.
Just enough.
⚜ ━━━━ ROYAL PROCLAMATION ━━━━ ⚜
Read more chapters for free in the public library:
unwrittenrealm.com
⚜ ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ ⚜
By order of the Crown.
The royal vault holds chapters the public throne room has yet to receive.
Noble — $7 — Twelve chapters ahead.
New chapters added weekly.
Full schedule posted in the war room.