💎 WEEKLY POWER GOALS 💎🔥 30→2ch | 60→5ch | 100→8ch | 200→15ch | 400→25ch⏰ Resets Monday!
~~~~❃❃~~~~~~~~❃❃~~~~
The Winterfell convoy returned to Karhold at dusk on the third day.
No advance message.
No scouts riding ahead to announce their arrival.
Rickard Karstark, Lord of Karhold, had never needed that kind of ceremony.
When his warhorse’s iron-shod hooves struck the stone flags of the main gate, the sound hit like muffled thunder, rolling through the gate passage, across the training yard, into the great hall, into every corner of every side chamber.
Aven stood waiting at the entrance to the great hall.
He wore a dark grey fitted tunic, the sunburst badge of House Karstark pinned at his collar, his short brown hair combed neat.
Sixteen years old, his back ramrod straight, hands hanging naturally at his sides, like a pine tree not yet fully grown, but long since bent by heavy snow, and still standing.
Rickard swung down from the saddle.
The movement was heavy.
His boots hit the ground and kicked up a puff of dust.
The Lord of Karhold was forty-five years old.
What the North’s winters had carved into his face were not wrinkles.
They were blade scars.
A Northman through and through.
He tossed the reins to a stable hand and strode toward the great hall.
As he passed Aven, his steps paused.
Just paused.
Then he kept walking.
His voice came back over his shoulder like a stone flung onto ice:
“Come in.”
Two words.
No name, no question, not even a glance.
But the weight of those two words was enough to make both door guards simultaneously pull in their necks.
Aven followed.
His boots found the same stone flags Rickard had crossed, step for step.
The study sat in the castle’s east wing, Rickard’s private territory.
It had no need of torches.
Two rows of iron brackets lined the walls, each holding solid blocks of burnstone, and the deep blue fire they gave off made the whole room feel like a ship’s cabin sunk to the bottom of the sea.
The bookshelves were packed with cowhide-bound ledgers and scrolls.
A map of the North lay spread across the desk, one corner pinned down by an unsheathed dagger, its edge worn pale from sharpening.
Rickard sat behind the desk.
No cushion on the chair, it was hewn from a single block of oak, hard and cold.
He stripped off his gloves, folded them once, and set them beside the map.
Then he raised his head and looked at Aven directly for the first time.
That gaze was a blade.
He studied the son standing before him.
Something in his mind turned over — the confusion of a man realizing he did not know this son as well as he thought — but iron will pressed it flat before it could surface.
“Close the door.”
Aven turned and shut it.
The hinges let out a low groan.
After that, the study held nothing but the quiet hum of the burnstone and the breathing of two men.
“Speak.” Rickard leaned back in his chair, fingers laced over his stomach.
“From the beginning.”
Aven stood before the desk, three paces out.
The distance was deliberate, not far enough to seem timid, not close enough to seem presumptuous.
His sixteen-year-old frame looked slight in front of his father.
His stance did not waver.
“Three days ago, word began spreading through the castle that Uncle Arnolf was planning to seize Karhold while you were away.” Aven’s voice was level, neither raised nor dropped, the tone of a man filing a report.
“I had men search his quarters.
They found a large quantity of weapons, including a siege crossbow of the kind only used in assaults on fortifications.
Under the laws of the realm, that is treason.”
Rickard said nothing.
His expression did not change.
But the set of his interlaced fingers shifted, his left thumb pressing down over his right, the pads covered in calluses ground in by decades of gripping a sword.
“So in my great hall,” he said, voice pressed out from his chest, low and steady, like thunder still far off but getting closer, “before my sworn men, you judged my own brother.”
Not a question.
A statement.
“Yes,” Aven said.
The study went quiet for a long time.
The burnstone’s light moved across Rickard’s face, throwing his shadow huge and still against the wall behind him.
“Those weapons,” Rickard finally said.
“Did you plant them?”
The question arrived like a straight punch with no windup.
Any man with a guilty conscience would have cracked right there, eyes sliding away, breath coming too fast, or an answer fired back too quickly.
Aven did none of those things.
He met his father’s eyes.
The grey-blue of his pupils held the burnstone’s reflection steady.
“When they were found, the weapons were already there.”
Word for word what he had said in the great hall.
Not one syllable different.
Rickard’s gaze drove into his face like a blacksmith’s tongs clamping onto red-hot iron.
Aven did not flinch.
He could feel that stare peeling back his skin, turning through his bones, hunting for any crack.
Any seam.
Then Rickard’s gaze pulled back.
Like a direwolf deciding the prey in front of it was not worth killing just yet, retracting its fangs, but not releasing its claws.
“Rumors.” Rickard’s voice carried a new layer: disappointment, cold enough to reach the bone.
“You convicted a man on rumors, then had him killed to keep him quiet.
Aven.
When did you become like this?”
“Father,” Aven said, “have you ever considered—”
“I asked you a question.” Rickard cut him off.
Not loud.
But the words hit like a stone dropped into still water, rings spreading from the desk to the walls, from the walls back into Aven’s chest.
“When did you become like this?”
This question was harder than “Did you plant the weapons?” Because answering it would expose everything.
That he was not the silent, withdrawn third son they thought they knew.
That a modern soul lived behind his eyes.
That he had not killed Arnolf for Karhold’s safety, he had killed him because he had read the script, and he knew who was supposed to die.
Aven was silent for two seconds.
“Father.
You show too much tolerance toward your kin.” His voice did not shake.
“And that tolerance will hurt even more of your kin.”
Rickard’s eyes changed.
When a father hears his sixteen-year-old son say that tolerance will hurt the people he loves, something cracks open in him whether he wants it to or not.
“Go on.” Rickard’s voice dropped slightly.
Not a command anymore.
A father, listening.
“Uncle Arnolf was never satisfied with your rule over Karhold.” Aven stepped half a pace forward and drew a palm-sized leather-bound ledger from inside his coat.
He set it on the desk and pushed it toward Rickard.
“This is what I found in his quarters.”
Rickard did not open it immediately.
He looked at the ledger.
Then at Aven.
“You found a ledger in his quarters.” No question in his voice.
But every word felt weighed.
“Yes.”
“You searched his quarters.
Went through his personal belongings.
Found a ledger.
Then sent men to kill him on the road.
And now you tell me all of it was to protect this family.”
Rickard picked up the ledger and opened it.
The burnstone’s light fell across yellowed pages covered in figures, grain shipments and their destinations, weapons procurement, a sum of silver stags from no clear source, and several expenditures marked “southward,” the amounts substantial, the purposes vague.
He turned the pages slowly.
Every page.
Every figure.
His expression never moved.
But when he reached the last few pages, the fingers turning the leaf stopped for just a moment.
Those pages recorded a slave trade.
The North keeps no slaves.
That rule had passed through eight thousand years of Stark lordship, from Brandon the Builder down to the present day, and not one generation had broken it.
For any Northern lord to be caught in slave trading was not merely a disgrace.
It was a death sentence.
Rickard closed the ledger.
He set it on the desk and pressed his palm flat on top of it.
His fingertips went faintly white.
Silence.
This silence was different from the one before.
The earlier silence had been an interrogation, a father examining his son.
This silence was something else.
A man trying to swallow something that would not go down.
“When did you start looking into him?” Rickard asked.
His voice was flat, without inflection.
But that cold, oppressive weight had returned, not aimed at any enemy in particular.
Aimed at everyone.
And everyone included his son.
When real evidence was laid on the table, the interrogation became a conversation.
➤ Next: Mercy — What Was Lost